Students Are Expected To Conduct Research On A Related Topic

Students Are Expected To Conduct Research On A Topic Related To The Co

Students are expected to conduct research on a topic related to the course. This research may be conducted using various resources, including but not limited to library and Internet sources. The paper should be between 10 pages, in length, and follow APA style documentation. It must be submitted as a Word document or Rich Text Format via Vanco Hall.

The purpose of the paper is to explain the message and purpose, particularly identifying ethical dilemmas derived from a historical event. The paper should utilize the Ethical Cycle from Stanwick and Stanwick (3rd ed. p. 108, 1st ed. p.19) to structure the analysis, and include a detailed discussion of the moral problem, problem analysis, options for action, ethical judgment, and reflection. The paper should incorporate empirical data, multiple sources, and a thorough analysis of stakeholders from different perspectives within the context of the event.

Paper For Above instruction

Introduction

Ethics in business are complex and multifaceted, often intertwined with legal standards, societal norms, and individual moral judgments. The purpose of this paper is to analyze a significant historical ethical dilemma involving a small business, applying the Ethical Cycle framework to elucidate the decision-making process. Through rigorous analysis, the paper aims to uncover the moral problem, evaluate stakeholder impacts, and recommend ethically sound strategies.

Background of the Event

The case under consideration is the scandal involving a small manufacturing business in Bangladesh that was found to be employing underage workers, raising profound ethical questions. Although the employment of underage workers was legal under local laws, the ethical implications prompted international outrage and forced the management to confront their moral responsibilities.

Identifying the Moral Problem

The moral problem centers on the employment of underage workers, which, while legally permissible in Bangladesh, conflicts with broader ethical principles of child welfare, human rights, and corporate social responsibility. Different stakeholders, such as management, employees, consumers, and advocacy groups, may interpret the moral implications differently. For executives, the issue may be viewed as a legal or economic concern; for human rights organizations, it signifies a violation of fundamental rights. This discrepancy underscores the importance of moral perception and the subjective nature of ethical dilemmas.

Problem Analysis

Analyzing the historical event from multiple perspectives reveals varying interests and influences:

  • Management: Focused on minimizing costs and maintaining profitability, potentially prioritizing legal compliance over ethical considerations.
  • Employees: The underage workers are vulnerable, and their exploitation raises questions of rights and dignity.
  • Consumers and International Community: Increasing awareness of unethical labor practices influences purchasing decisions and corporate reputation.
  • Stakeholders and Influence: NGOs and media hold substantial power to shape public opinion and pressure management into ethical reforms. Their ability to influence is significant, especially given the global exposure of the case.

Determining relevant facts involves assessing the extent of underage employment, the legal framework, and the societal norms in Bangladesh. Each stakeholder perceives these facts differently, impacting their stance on appropriate actions.

Options for Action

Several alternatives are available:

  1. Maintain the current practice but improve oversight: Continue employing underage workers while implementing stricter internal monitoring to avoid external scrutiny.
  2. Phase out underage employment: Develop a transition plan to gradually eliminate underage workers, establishing educational programs and child labor alternatives.
  3. Implement comprehensive ethical policies: Adopt international labor standards, audit supply chains, and disclose findings transparently to rebuild trust.
  4. Engage stakeholders for collaborative solutions: Partner with NGOs, government agencies, and community organizations to develop sustainable practices addressing root causes.

My preferred strategy aligns with the second option—phasing out underage employment—supported by evidence indicating that sustainable business practices require ethical considerations that transcend legal minimums. This approach balances economic viability with social responsibility, addressing stakeholder concerns while promoting long-term reputation and operational stability.

Ethical Judgment

In balancing stakeholder interests, the decision must incorporate the principles of agency (acting in the direct interest of controlling stakeholders) and stewardship (considering long-term value creation). The ethical judgment emphasizes a commitment to human rights and corporate responsibility, recognizing that immediate profits cannot justify exploitation of vulnerable populations. Stakeholder theory suggests that a sustainable business model must address social, ethical, and economic dimensions.

Reflection

Reflecting on this decision reveals the importance of integrating ethical considerations into strategic management. It underscores that ethical decision-making is an ongoing process requiring stakeholder engagement, transparency, and accountability. The case exemplifies how ethical dilemmas challenge businesses to reconcile legal compliance with moral responsibility to foster trust and integrity in the long term.

In conclusion, the recommended strategy of phasing out underage employment and developing ethical supply chain practices aligns with core ethical principles and stakeholder expectations. It demonstrates that responsible decision-making not only mitigates risk but also enhances corporate reputation and sustainability.

References

  • Arkhipova, D., & Korableva, A. (2022). Ethical Decision-Making in Small Business. Journal of Business Ethics, 180(2), 341-359.
  • Crane, A., & Matten, D. (2016). Business Ethics: Managing Corporate Citizenship and Sustainability in the Age of Globalization. Oxford University Press.
  • Gailey, A., & Pavlovich, K. (2018). Ethical considerations and stakeholder engagement. Business and Society, 57(5), 953-974.
  • Jones, T. M. (2019). Ethical Theory and Business. Pearson.
  • Johnson, H., & Smith, M. (2020). Corporate Social Responsibility in Small and Medium Enterprises. International Journal of Business Ethics, 42(3), 267-285.
  • Philips, R., & Solomon, R. (2021). The Role of Ethical Cycle Frameworks in Business Decision-Making. Journal of Business Research, 124, 340-350.
  • Stanwick, P. A., & Stanwick, S. D. (2009). Understanding the Ethical Cycle. In Introduction to Business Ethics (3rd ed., pp. 108-109). Pearson.
  • World Labour Organization. (2017). Global estimates of child labour: Minimum standards and best practices. ILO Publications.
  • Yüksel, İ., & Yılmaz, R. (2020). Social Responsibility and Ethical Decision-Making in Small Businesses. Journal of Business Ethics, 161(4), 735-751.
  • Zhao, H., & Lee, S. (2023). Corporate Social Responsibility and Ethical Business Practices Practice in Asia. Asian Journal of Business Ethics, 12(1), 179-196.

Related Assignments