WestJet Case Analysis: Maintaining Culture During Expansion

WestJet Case Analysis: Maintaining Culture During Expansion

This report is on WestJet Airlines LTD. It will tell you about WestJet Airline strengths and weaknesses and its long-term strategy. Moreover, a critical analysis is given that will help you to understand WestJet and its competitor’s position in the airline market by highlighting some important factors. And in the end, some alternatives and solutions with the best of alternatives will be provided. Comment by Fac-Staff: You need to identify a major issue before you start your analysis and give your recommendation.

WestJet airline is a discount airline based in Canada, celebrated for its success and unique company culture. Its appeal derives from offering low fares coupled with friendly and high-quality services, which have garnered positive customer ratings. The company's emphasis on trust, respect, teamwork, and an informal, fun environment contributes significantly to its operational excellence. Employees are treated equally, regardless of race, religion, or professional qualification, fostering a loyal and motivated workforce. Their culture promotes collaboration, where employees are willing to perform tasks outside their formal job descriptions to ensure smooth operations. Such a positive work environment reflects directly on customer satisfaction, underpinning WestJet's market position (Robert, 2003).

Nevertheless, despite its strengths, WestJet faces significant challenges, largely stemming from its planned expansion. The primary concern is whether rapid growth can be achieved without compromising its defining culture. Expansion necessitates hiring new personnel, which risks diluting or disrupting the existing corporate culture that values informality, teamwork, and employee autonomy. A notable example is the resignation of Steve Smith, who was hired as CEO in 1999 but resigned in late 2000 due to inability to fit into WestJet’s unique culture (Hildreth, 2003). His departure highlights the difficulty of maintaining cultural coherence amid growth and personnel changes.

The company’s culture is both a strength and a vulnerability. While it has enabled WestJet to cultivate a cohesive and motivated workforce committed to service excellence, it also poses difficulties in integrating new employees during rapid expansion. When new hires are unfamiliar or uncomfortable with this culture, performance can suffer, leading to dissatisfaction among staff and customers alike. Employees feeling disconnected or alienated may resist organizational norms, leading to a decline in service quality, increased turnover, or even unionization, which conflicts with WestJet’s trust-based model (Bercuson, 2000).

To address these issues, WestJet must carefully manage its expansion strategies to preserve its core culture. One approach is to limit rapid growth by opening fewer branches at a time, allowing better cultural integration and workforce stability. Alternatively, the company can adopt more rigorous selection and training procedures. Hiring experienced personnel and shadowing them for a period before full integration can ensure cultural fit. Extensive training programs for new employees should incorporate scenarios and problem-solving exercises relevant to their roles, fostering a shared understanding of company values and operational standards. These measures can mitigate the risk of cultural dilution and maintain high service levels.

Among these options, the most effective strategy appears to be a combination of hiring new staff and providing comprehensive training. This approach leverages the fresh perspectives of new hires while ensuring they are aligned with WestJet’s culture before assuming full responsibilities. Such training can include role-playing, peer mentoring, and scenario-based assessments to evaluate their reaction to typical work situations and customer interactions (Hildreth, 2003). Moreover, involving current employees and management in the training process promotes cultural continuity and reinforces organizational values.

In addition to internal personnel strategies, WestJet should consider gradual expansion, opening new branches incrementally rather than en masse. This phased approach allows for ongoing cultural assessment and adjustment, thereby reducing disruption. It also provides opportunities to refine hiring and training processes, ensuring consistency in service quality and employee engagement. The CEO, Beddoe, should champion these measures, leveraging his credibility to unify the organization’s efforts and secure employee buy-in.

Another critical factor is leveraging technology to support service delivery and operational efficiency. Implementing mobile applications, online booking systems, and in-flight entertainment enhancements can improve customer experience and streamline operations without requiring significant increases in staffing. These technological advances should be aligned with the company’s culture of innovation and customer-centricity, further strengthening competitive advantage (Robert, 2003).

Paper For Above instruction

WestJet Airlines has established a reputation as a distinguished Canadian airline through its commitment to low fares, exemplary customer service, and a corporate culture rooted in trust, camaraderie, and fun. Its success hinges on a unique organizational ethos that emphasizes teamwork, equality, and employee satisfaction, which positively influences customer experiences and operational performance. However, as the airline contemplates rapid expansion to increase market share and international presence, these core cultural elements face significant threats.

The fundamental problem confronting WestJet is maintaining its distinctive corporate culture amid accelerated growth. The risk is that new employees, unfamiliar with or resistant to the established culture, may inadvertently erode the very environment that fosters their productivity and customer loyalty. The case of CEO Steve Smith’s resignation in 2000 exemplifies this challenge—his departure was attributed to an inability to assimilate into WestJet’s unique cultural fabric, highlighting the peril of cultural dissonance during leadership transitions and expansion phases (Hildreth, 2003).

Critical analysis reveals that WestJet’s culture is both a strategic asset and a potential liability. Its strength lies in fostering a motivated workforce that delivers high-quality service with enthusiasm and authenticity. Conversely, this culture's informality and emphasis on employee autonomy can hinder integration of new staff and lead to inconsistency once growth accelerates. The potential for tension among employees, the erosion of trust, and increased likelihood of unionization are concerns that need addressing to sustain long-term success.

To mitigate these risks, WestJet must implement strategic human resource interventions. One effective measure is phased geographic expansion—opening new branches gradually to allow for comprehensive cultural onboarding and integration efforts. This approach minimizes organizational shocks and provides opportunities to fine-tune hiring and training strategies. Additionally, rigorously selecting experienced personnel and integrating them through shadowing ensures they understand and embody WestJet’s cultural norms from the outset. Such employment of experience combined with extensive training, including role-playing and scenario analysis, equips staff to uphold the service standards integral to WestJet’s brand (Bercuson, 2000).

Recommendations to optimize this process include engaging current employees in developing training modules that reflect real-world scenarios, fostering a sense of shared purpose. Involving management in mentorship roles can reinforce culture and facilitate knowledge transfer. Furthermore, leveraging technology to support training and service excellence enhances operational efficiency and customer satisfaction, aligning with WestJet’s innovative and customer-oriented values (Robert, 2003).

Conclusively, the optimal strategy for WestJet involves a balanced approach—limiting rapid expansion while investing in comprehensive, culture-preserving training and hiring practices. This dual focus will enable the airline to grow sustainably without sacrificing its core identity. Continuing to foster a happy, motivated workforce committed to excellence will ensure that WestJet remains competitive, retains customer loyalty, and sustains its reputation as one of the premier airlines in Canada.

References

• Bercuson, K. (2000). Singapore: a Case Study in Rapid Development. Washington: International Monetary Fund.
• Hildreth, W. (2003). Case Studies in Public Budgeting and Financial Management (Revised and Expanded). Florida: CRC Press.
• Robert, K. (2003). Case Study Research: Design and Methods. Singapore: SAGE Publications.
• Johnson, G., Scholes, K., & Whittington, R. (2008). Exploring Strategy. Pearson Education.
• Grant, R. M. (2019). Contemporary Strategy Analysis. Wiley.
• Porter, M. E. (1998). Competitive Strategy: Techniques for Analyzing Industries and Competitors. Free Press.
• Hitt, M. A., Ireland, R. D., & Hoskisson, R. E. (2017). Strategic Management: Concepts and Cases. Cengage Learning.
• Barney, J. B., & Hesterly, W. S. (2015). Strategic Management and Competitive Advantage. Pearson.
• Christensen, C. M., & Raynor, M. E. (2013). The Innovator's Solution: Creating and Sustaining Successful Growth. Harvard Business Review Press.
• Fombrun, C. J., & Van Riel, C. B. M. (2004). Fame & Fortune: How Successful Companies Build Winning Reputation. Pearson Education.