What Does Dr. Kimmel Mean When He Says Gender Is About The C

What Does Dr Kimmel Mean When He Says Gender Is About The Changing M

What does Dr. Kimmel mean when he says "gender is about the changing meanings of the fact of being male or female; that those are culturally constructed; that they change from culture to culture and over time"? Can you give specific examples of different meanings of being male or female over the course of life—that is, different meanings when you're a child, teenager, adult, or elderly? How about differences in gender meanings across different cultures? Pick a different culture than the United States, and give an example where the definition of "men-ness" or "women-ness" vary drastically, based on time of life or other factors (class status, and so on.)

Paper For Above instruction

Dr. Michael Kimmel, a renowned gender theorist and sociologist, emphasizes that gender is not an innate biological trait but rather a set of cultural meanings assigned to being male or female. According to Kimmel, these meanings are fluid, context-dependent, and subject to change over time and across different societies. This perspective underscores the concept that gender roles and expectations are socially constructed rather than biologically predetermined, and they evolve in response to cultural shifts, historical periods, and social structures.

Gender as a Dynamic and Culturally Constructed Concept

Kimmel’s assertion that gender encompasses "the changing meanings of the fact of being male or female" highlights the fluidity of gender identities and expectations. For example, the roles and attributes associated with masculinity and femininity are not fixed. Instead, they are shaped by cultural norms, societal values, and historical contexts. These meanings can shift dramatically over generations and between societies, reflecting the diversity and variability inherent in gender constructs.

Gender Meanings Across Different Life Stages

Throughout an individual's life, the societal meanings attached to being male or female can vary significantly. During childhood, gender roles are often simple and rigid: boys might be expected to be assertive, competitive, and independent, while girls are encouraged to be nurturing, passive, and caring. These early expectations are reinforced through societal norms, media portrayals, and familial reinforcement.

As children grow into adolescence, these gender meanings become more complex and sometimes conflictual. Teenagers are often subjected to societal pressures to conform to certain gendered behaviors, such as boys demonstrating dominance or independence, and girls focusing on appearance and relational skills. During this period, gender identities may be explored or challenged, leading to a more nuanced understanding of what it means to be male or female.

In adulthood, gender meanings are often tied to social roles and expectations within the workplace, family responsibilities, and community involvement. For men, being "masculine" might involve career success, emotional stoicism, or authority, while for women, it might involve balancing career and family, nurturing others, and maintaining social relationships. Interestingly, these roles often become more flexible or redefined in later stages of life; for the elderly, gender may take on different meanings, such as being a wise elder or a caretaker, reflecting a societal appreciation for experience and maturity.

Cross-Cultural Variations in Gender Definitions

Beyond individual life stages, the cultural context significantly influences gender meanings. An example from a non-U.S. culture is the concept of "Bissu" in Indonesia’s Bugis society. The Bissu are considered a blend of male and female qualities and are recognized as a distinct gender category that challenges Western binary notions of gender. Their role in society is spiritual, serving as clergy and mediators, and their gender identity encompasses aspects of both masculinity and femininity. This cultural interpretation of gender varies drastically from the binary understanding prevalent in Western societies.

Similarly, in the Indian caste system, gender roles are often rigidly tied to social class and caste. Women from higher castes traditionally had the role of maintaining chastity and domestic responsibilities, while lower caste women might have been engaged in labor-intensive work, with less emphasis on prescribed gender virtues. Over time, especially in urban and progressive contexts, these definitions are shifting, but historically, they exemplified how cultural and social variables influence gender expectations dramatically.

Gender as a Fluid and Contextual Concept

In summary, Dr. Kimmel’s perspective that gender is about the changing meanings highlights the importance of understanding gender as a social construct that varies over time, across societies, and within different life stages. The fluidity of gender roles demonstrates that these are not fixed attributes but are subject to ongoing cultural negotiations and reinterpretations. Recognizing these variations fosters a broader understanding of gender diversity globally, emphasizing the importance of cultural sensitivity and awareness in gender studies.

References

• Bockting, W. O., et al. (2013). Transgender and gender nonconforming people. In B. M. Ehrenreich & D. T. Hochschild (Eds.), Global Women's Health (pp. 359–376). University of California Press.
• Cameron, D. (1997). Verbal Hygiene. Routledge.
• Connell, R. W. (2005). Toward a new paradigm for masculinity. American Journal of Sociology, 109(2), 659-663.
• Connell, R. W., & Messerschmidt, J. W. (2005). Hegemonic masculinity: Rethinking the concept. Gender & Society, 19(6), 829-859.
• Jackson, S. (2012). Gender, sexuality & society. Palgrave Macmillan.
• Jackson, S., & Scott, S. (Eds.). (2010). Theorizing Sexualities. Wiley-Blackwell.
• Kimmel, M. (2008). Manhood in America: A cultural history. Johns Hopkins University Press.
• Lie, M. (2010). The social life of gender: Exploring gender in cultural contexts. Gender, Place & Culture, 17(3), 365-377.
• West, C., & Zimmerman, D. H. (1987). Doing gender. Gender & Society, 1(2), 125-151.
• Young, I. M. (1990). Justice and the Politics of Difference. Princeton University Press.