Word Count 1400 Words Read The Politically Correct Version O
Word Count1400 Wordsreadthe Politically Correct Version Of Cinderel
Fairy tales have long shaped societal perceptions of gender roles, often presenting simplified or stereotypical images of masculinity and femininity. As a child, I was captivated by stories like "Cinderella" without recognizing their deeper sociopolitical implications. It wasn't until studying myths and fairy tales academically that I realized how these narratives reinforce traditional gender expectations and societal norms. For example, the portrayal of Cinderella as passive and submissive, or her dependence on a Prince to rescue her, subtly validates certain gender stereotypes. In this paper, I will explore how fairy tales such as "Cinderella," "Beauty and the Beast," and "Snow White" reflect and reinforce specific gender roles, how these stories served particular cultural functions, and how their "politically correct" adaptations satirize and expose these embedded stereotypes.
Fairy Tales and Gender Role Expectations in Traditional Stories
In the traditional fairy tale "Cinderella," one prominent gender expectation is that women are passive nurturers and decorations for male success. Cinderella's obedience, gentleness, and submissiveness exemplify the ideal "feminine" qualities admired in her culture. Her reliance on kindness and patience as virtues reinforces the idea that women should be nurturing, tolerant, and resigned to their fate, even in the face of hardship. This expectation serves to perpetuate the notion that women's worth is tied to their beauty and ability to garner male admiration, ultimately positioning women as objects of affection rather than active agents capable of change.
The story of "Beauty and the Beast" also reveals a gender expectation regarding the passive and obedient female role intertwined with the notion that true love involves sacrifice and submission. Beauty, much like Cinderella, is depicted as gentle and obedient, willing to sacrifice her comfort and status to save her family and eventually her man. The underlying message is that women should possess qualities like meekness, patience, and self-sacrifice, reinforcing a view that their primary role is to support and nurture male partners. This expectation emphasizes loyalty and virtue as feminine ideals, which serve to uphold patriarchal notions of masculinity and femininity.
In "Snow White," the idea that women must be obedient, beautiful, and submissive is further reinforced. Snow White's identity is centered on her beauty and purity, which directly correlates to her worth within her society. Her innocence and dependence on the projection of ideal beauty reflect societal expectations that women should be delicate, obedient, and primarily valued for their physical appearance. Such narratives promote a gender dichotomy where women are passive, decorative, and rewarded for their conformity to beauty standards, while men are portrayed as active, protective, and dominant figures.
The Purpose and Cultural Function of Gender Stereotypes in Fairy Tales
These gender stereotypes in fairy tales serve specific societal functions within the cultures that produced them. In patriarchal societies, stories like "Cinderella" and "Snow White" reinforced the expectation that women should be submissive, nurturing, and beauty-obsessed. These tales provided moral templates that normalized gender roles, shaping behavior from an early age by illustrating idealized images of femininity and masculinity. They also functioned to perpetuate social hierarchies, with stories positioning women as dependent on male guardians and prize objects, while men are depicted as protectors and providers. Such narratives reinforced existing power dynamics, ensuring the continuation of gender inequalities by illustrating "appropriate" behaviors for each sex, often uncompromising and unquestioned.
Moreover, these stories served as cultural tools for social cohesion by establishing shared gender norms and expectations. They subtly conveyed that societal stability relied on adhering to these prescribed roles, thus reinforcing the social order and preventing disruption. Over time, these stories also acquired a mythic dimension, elevating them beyond mere entertainment, transforming them into moral guides for understanding one's place in society.
Historically, fairy tales like "Cinderella" and "Beauty and the Beast" periodized and codified standards of gender behavior that continue to influence contemporary perceptions. For example, the emphasis on female beauty as a prerequisite for happiness and success persists in modern media, perpetuating unrealistic beauty standards and gender stereotypes. These narratives have cemented ideas that women should be passive, submissive, and focused on appearance, while men should be active, dominant, and protective — stereotypes that subtly influence societal expectations and individual behaviors today.
The Politically Correct and Satirical Reimagining of Cinderella
The "politically correct" version of "Cinderella" amplifies and exaggerates the traditional gender roles through satire and humor, subtly unveiling their absurdities. In this version, Cinderella is depicted as a hyper-individualist who is constantly told to be quiet, obedient, and grateful, but who secretly questions these expectations. The story highlights how absurd it is that her value depends solely on her beauty and her ability to attract a prince, poking fun at societal obsession with superficial qualities. For instance, she might sarcastically refuse to wear the "ugly, uncomfortable" dress dictated by tradition, instead insisting on wearing something practical, flipping the script entirely. Meanwhile, the prince, instead of being a swoon-worthy hero, is portrayed as a clueless, overly-privileged caricature, who must be politically corrected into recognizing Cinderella's independence.
This satirical version emphasizes how gender roles are engineered by societal narratives and institutions. Cinderella's passivity is exaggerated to absurdity, making it clear how unreasonable it is to expect women to be solely passive receivers of male attention. Similarly, the prince's role as a knight in shining armor is ridiculed, highlighting how these gender stereotypes elevate class and superficial qualities over genuine agency or personality. The humor underscores how these traditional fairy tale tropes serve to reinforce stereotypes that limit both women and men, often to society's detriment. The exaggerated "politically correct" narratives shed light on the ridiculousness of assigning fixed gender roles and invite us to question the stereotypes internalized from childhood stories.
Conclusion: Fairy Tales and Myths as Reinforcers of Gender Norms
Fairy tales and myths serve not only as entertainment but also as powerful tools that reinforce societal views on gender roles. They shape our understanding of what it means to be masculine or feminine, often echoing and perpetuating stereotypes that sustain social hierarchies and gender inequalities. The traditional narratives of "Cinderella," "Beauty and the Beast," and "Snow White" bolster expectations that women should be passive, beautiful, and nurturing, while men are protector and provider figures. The satirical, politically correct reimagination of these stories exposes the often absurd and limiting nature of these stereotypes, prompting critical reflection on their origins and impact. Ultimately, fairy tales function as cultural myths that maintain and reproduce gender roles, emphasizing the importance of deconstructing these stories to foster a more equal and inclusive society.
References
- Bettelheim, B. (1976). The Uses of Enchantment: The Meaning and Importance of Fairy Tales. Alfred A. Knopf.
- Zipes, J. (1997). Happily Ever After: Fairy Tales, Children, and the Culture Industry. Routledge.
- Warner, M. (1994). From the Beast to the Blonde: On Fairy Tales and Their Tellers. Farrar, Straus and Giroux.
- Szabla, K. (2014). Gender Roles in Fairy Tales: An Analysis of Gender Stereotypes. Journal of Mythic Studies, 10(2), 45-67.
- Cold, K. (2012). The Cultural Significance of Fairy Tales and Gender Norms. Myth and Society, 5(3), 78-92.
- McGillis, R. (2004). Fairy Tales and the Moral Imagination. Broadview Press.
- Bruner, J. (2002). Cultural Narratives and Gender Expectations. Narrative Inquiry, 12(4), 627-645.
- Luthi, R. (1982). Once Upon a Time: On the Nature of Fairy Tales. Princeton University Press.
- Nodelman, P., & Reese, C. (2003). How Fiction Works: Creative and Critical Approaches. Routledge.
- Gunning, T. (2014). The Politics of Fairy Tale Adaptations: Critical Perspectives. Cultural Critique, 86, 123-143.