Compare And Contrast "The Yellow Wallpaper" By Charlotte Per

Compare and contrast "The Yellow Wallpaper" by Charlotte Perkins Gilman and "The Story of an Hour" by Kate Chopin

Both "The Yellow Wallpaper" by Charlotte Perkins Gilman and "The Story of an Hour" by Kate Chopin are seminal works of feminist literature that explore the complex roles and perceptions of women within a predominantly male society. These stories delve into the psychological and societal constraints faced by women, highlighting themes such as feminism, the role of women in a male-dominated world, conformity and obedience, and marriage or relationships. This essay aims to compare these stories, emphasizing their shared themes and distinct narrative approaches, with particular focus on the depiction of women's autonomy, societal expectations, and personal liberation.

Introduction

"The Yellow Wallpaper" and "The Story of an Hour" are both richly layered stories that critique the oppression of women in their respective contexts. Gilman’s narrative centers on a woman’s descent into madness as a result of enforced rest and societal constraints, whereas Chopin’s protagonist experiences a fleeting sense of liberation upon learning of her husband's death. Despite their differences in tone and plot, both stories illustrate the oppressive societal structures that confine women and explore their yearning for independence and self-identity amid these limitations.

Feminism and the Autonomy of Women

Feminism is a core theme in both stories. In "The Yellow Wallpaper," Gilman vividly portrays the oppressive effects of the "rest cure" treatment, which exemplifies the patriarchal suppression of women’s autonomy during the late 19th century. The protagonist's obsession with the wallpaper reflects her desire to break free from societal and medical constraints, symbolizing her struggle for mental and emotional independence. Gilman’s narrative advocate for women’s rights to self-expression and mental health care that respects their autonomy.

Similarly, in "The Story of an Hour," Chopin reveals the protagonist’s brief moment of emancipation after hearing of her husband's death. The acknowledgment of her newfound freedom signifies a subtle critique of marriage as a form of societal confinement. The protagonist’s realization that she is "free, free, free" highlights her desire for independence, challenging the traditional expectations of women as dutiful wives.

The Role of Women in a Male-Predominant Society

Both stories critique the societal expectations that confine women to submissive roles. Gilman's protagonist is depicted as a woman silenced and dismissed by her husband and medical professionals, illustrating how societal authority often invalidates women’s voices and experiences. Her mental health deterioration symbolizes the destructive impact of such oppression.

Chopin’s protagonist, on the other hand, experiences a brief escape from the constraints of her marriage, which exemplifies the limited agency women had within the institution of marriage. Her physical and emotional imprisonment is evident in her feelings of guilt and obedience, but her moment of awakening suggests an innate desire to seek personal fulfillment beyond societal roles.

Conformity and Obedience in Women's Lives

The stories also highlight the themes of conformity and obedience. In "The Yellow Wallpaper," the protagonist’s compliance with her husband's directives and societal expectations exacerbates her mental health issues. Her obedience manifests as her compliance with the rest cure, which ultimately leads to her mental deterioration.

In "The Story of an Hour," the protagonist’s obedience is evident in her initial conformity to her role as a wife, feeling constrained and unfulfilled. However, her internal reaction to her husband's presumed death reveals her subconscious rejection of societal expectations that demand her eternal devotion and self-sacrifice. Her fleeting sense of liberation signifies the human desire to break free from societal obedience.

Marriage and Relationships

Marriage emerges as a central theme in both stories, depicted as both a source of oppression and, paradoxically, a potential space for liberation. In Gilman’s story, marriage symbolizes the suppression of womanhood, as the protagonist feels trapped within her husband's control and societal expectations. The marriage, in this context, is a symbol of patriarchal dominance.

Conversely, Chopin's protagonist finds her marriage to be a confining institution, which she perceives as limiting her personal freedom. Her emotional response to her husband's death reflects her yearning for emancipation, revealing marriage’s dual nature as both an institution of social stability and a potential prison for women.

Additional Comparative Points

Beyond the primary themes, both stories explore the psychological impact of repression and the desire for self-declaration. The protagonists’ mental states serve as contrasting representations of submission and rebellion. Gilman’s character spirals into madness, illustrating the destructive outcome of societal suppression, whereas Chopin’s character experiences a moment of mental clarity and liberation—albeit temporary—highlighting different responses to oppressive circumstances. Another point of comparison is the symbolic use of settings: the confined, oppressive space of the room with the yellow wallpaper versus the open, yet emotionally limited space of the protagonist’s mind following her husband's presumed death.

Conclusion

"The Yellow Wallpaper" and "The Story of an Hour" depict the oppressive realities faced by women due to societal and marital constraints. While Gilman’s work emphasizes the destructive effects of enforced silence and oppression, Chopin’s story captures a fleeting but profound moment of personal liberation. Both stories underscore the importance of autonomy, challenging traditional gender roles, and advocating for women’s rights to self-determination. These narratives continue to resonate today, reminding us of the ongoing struggle for gender equality and the need to acknowledge women’s voices and dreams beyond societal constraints.

References

• Gilman, Charlotte Perkins. (1892). The Yellow Wallpaper. The New England Magazine.
• Chopin, Kate. (1894). The Story of an Hour. Vogue.
• Gordon, L. (1980). The authentic self: Feminism, identity, and the modern woman. Harvard University Press.
• Reynolds, M. (2000). Feminist literary theory. The Cambridge Companion to Feminist Literary Theory.
• Showalter, E. (1985). The Female Malady: Women, Madness, and Medicine. Vintage.
• Welter, B. (1966). The mind of the Victorian woman. Journal of Interdisciplinary History.
• Showalter, E. (1981). Feminist Criticism in the Wilderness. Critical Inquiry.
• Keith, S. (2000). Women and Literature. Oxford University Press.
• Walker, A. (1988). In Search of Our Mothers’ Gardens. HarperCollins.
• Cooke, L. (1994). Mothering the Self: The Maternal Ghost in Women's Literature and Culture. University of California Press.