Create A Criteria Sheet, Review Checklist Or Table Off ✓ Solved

Create A Criteria Sheetthis Isa Review Checklistor Table Offive Crite

Create a criteria sheet. This is a review checklist or table of five criteria that you will use to prepare your peer review of your classmate's resume. Your criteria can be what you choose to be appropriate for this review, but the criteria must be constructive, objective, and relevant for reviewing a resume. Include a References page of at least 2 research sources you utilized in creating your checklist. (One would be the Indeed.com source, for example.) Save your Criteria Sheet to submit to this Assignment. Review your assigned classmate's resume using the checklist you created.

Using the attached template, write 2 to 3 page peer review for your classmate providing feedback about the resume. Your tone should be collegial and sensitive, but provide constructive, relevant feedback. Simply saying “nice job,” “great resume,” etc., is not a review and is not constructive. Explain both what is effective and why (i.e., including the positive), and what could be improved and why. Refer to the criteria you chose for your review. Consider what you hope to see as feedback on the review of your resume.

Sample Paper For Above instruction

Peer Review of Resume Based on Established Criteria

Introduction

The purpose of this peer review is to provide constructive feedback on the resume submitted by my classmate, ensuring that it effectively highlights their skills, experience, and qualifications. To guide this review, I established a criteria sheet comprising five specific, objective, and relevant criteria for evaluating resumes. These criteria include clarity of formatting, relevance and strength of content, clarity of career objectives, language and tone, and overall professionalism.

Criteria 1: Clarity of Formatting

This criterion assesses whether the resume is well-organized, easy to read, and visually appealing. A well-formatted resume should have clear headings, consistent font usage, and appropriate spacing. In the submitted resume, the formatting is clean, with consistent use of bold headings and bullet points which enhance readability. However, some sections could benefit from further emphasis, such as highlighting key skills or achievements to draw immediate attention. Clear formatting helps recruiters quickly find pertinent information, which is essential in a competitive job market (Indeed.com, 2023).

Criteria 2: Relevance and Strength of Content

The content should be tailored to the specific job or industry, demonstrating relevant skills and accomplishments. In this resume, the candidate has included valuable experience in project management and customer service. Nonetheless, further detail regarding measurable achievements—such as increased sales percentages or successful project completions—would strengthen the impact of their experience. Including keywords from the job description also improves the resume’s relevance, increasing the chance of passing applicant tracking systems (ATS) (Smith & Johnson, 2021).

Criteria 3: Clarity of Career Objectives

A clear career objective guides the reader and aligns the candidate's goals with the prospective position. The current resume includes a concise objective statement specifying a desire to leverage project management skills in a dynamic organization. This clarity helps recruiters understand the candidate’s professional focus and career path, making it more likely for their resume to stand out among other applicants.

Criteria 4: Language and Tone

The language used should be professional, concise, and confident. The resume employs active verbs and avoids jargon, making the candidate's skills and accomplishments compelling. For example, phrases like “led a team of 10” and “implemented process improvements” demonstrate proactive engagement. Using confident language enhances credibility and leaves a positive impression (Harvard Business Review, 2020).

Criteria 5: Overall Professionalism

Overall professionalism encompasses grammatical accuracy, consistent formatting, and an appropriate tone. The candidate’s resume is free from spelling and grammatical errors, which conveys attention to detail. The presentation is polished, with uniform font sizes and spacing. These elements collectively contribute to a professional appearance, thereby increasing the candidate’s chances of being shortlisted.

Conclusion

In summary, the resume effectively employs clear formatting and demonstrates relevant experience and goals. To improve, the candidate could enhance their content by quantifying achievements and incorporating industry-specific keywords. My recommendations align with the criteria I established, which emphasize clarity, relevance, professionalism, and targeted language. Constructive feedback focused on these areas can help the applicant refine their resume and improve their chances of success.

References

  • Harvard Business Review. (2020). Effective Resume Writing Tips. https://hbr.org
  • Indeed.com. (2023). Resume Tips & Examples. https://www.indeed.com
  • Smith, A., & Johnson, L. (2021). Enhancing ATS Compatibility: Resume Optimization Strategies. Journal of Career Development, 45(3), 123-130.
  • CareerOneStop. (2022). Resume and CV Tips. U.S. Department of Labor.https://www.careeronestop.org
  • Monster.com. (2022). How to Write a Resume. https://www.monster.com