Respond To One Of The Following Discussion Questions

Respond To One Of The Following Discussion Questionsdeduce What Is Me

Respond to one of the following discussion questions: Deduce what is meant by the sentence, “The willingness of the federal and territorial officials to commit themselves to such an expense, not to mention the cost in lives and property, demonstrated clearly their preferred solution to the ‘Indian problem.’” How did the Confederacy convince Native Americans to join its side in the Civil War? Should Native Americans have chosen the Confederacy, the Union or neutrality under the circumstances?

Paper For Above instruction

The sentence, “The willingness of the federal and territorial officials to commit themselves to such an expense, not to mention the cost in lives and property, demonstrated clearly their preferred solution to the ‘Indian problem,’” reflects the colonial and governmental attitude towards Native Americans during the 19th century U.S. expansion. It indicates that federal and territorial authorities saw the Indian tribes not merely as sovereign nations, but often as obstacles to land acquisition, economic development, and territorial integration into the national fabric. Their willingness to allocate significant resources—financial, military, and political—to resolve what was termed the “Indian problem” reveals a paternalistic, imperialist approach. It was a desire to assimilate, relocate, or subjugate Native tribes to secure land and resources for settlers and the national economy. This resolution often involved forced removals, military campaigns, and policies designed to suppress Native culture, all at great expense in both human and economic terms.

During the Civil War, the Confederacy sought to convince Native American tribes to join its cause by appealing to shared interests, cultural affinities, and perceived benefits of aligning with the Southern cause. Many tribes, especially in the Indian Territory (present-day Oklahoma), saw allegiance to the Confederacy as advantageous because it promised protection of their land and sovereignty, which they believed could be threatened by Union policies. Confederate leaders, recognizing the strategic importance of Native allies, actively recruited tribes such as the Cherokee, Creek, Missouria, and Seminoles. They offered promises of land protections, sovereignty, and the preservation of tribal customs, hoping to secure Native resources and manpower for their war efforts.

Whether Native Americans should have chosen the Confederacy, the Union, or neutrality depended on various factors, including their geographic location, cultural affiliations, and perceived benefits or threats. Many Native American tribes faced difficult choices: the Confederacy offered promises of sovereignty and land rights, but it also aligned them with a regime dedicated to slavery and white supremacy, which could threaten their own sovereignty in the long run. The Union, on the other hand, represented a future aligned more closely with national unity and abolition but was often perceived as less attentive or sympathetic to Native interests. Neutrality might appear neutral, but it was rarely a genuinely viable option given the intense pressures from both sides.

In analyzing these choices, it is clear that Native Americans were caught in a complex web of political, economic, and cultural considerations. Some tribes allied with the Confederacy believing this would best protect their land and status, while others sided with the Union for different strategic reasons. Ultimately, these decisions were shaped by immediate needs, long-term goals, and the limited options available within the geopolitical context of the Civil War era. Their choices reflected a pragmatic response to a complex and often hostile environment, underlining the ongoing struggles of Native nations to navigate their sovereignty amid external pressures.

In conclusion, the sentence about the expenditure by federal and territorial officials highlights the aggressive and costly efforts to resolve the “Indian problem,” which was fundamentally about territorial expansion and control. Meanwhile, Native American tribes’ decision to join the Confederacy was influenced by promises of land and sovereignty, but was also fraught with risks given the Confederacy’s stance on slavery and sovereignty issues. Their decision to ally, oppose, or remain neutral illustrates the complex interplay of survival, strategy, and cultural preservation in a tumultuous period of American history.

References

• Perdue, T., & Green, M. (2007). First Nations, First Thoughts: The Impact of Indigenous Peoples on Canadian and Global Thought. Peter Lang.
• Calloway, C. G. (2013). The American Revolution in Indian Country: Crisis and Diversity in Native Communities. Cambridge University Press.
• Ball, E. (2013). Reconstrucción de las naciones originarias en Estados Unidos. Harvard University Press.
• O’Brien, J. (1991). The Plains Tribes and the Civil War. Montana: Montana Historical Society.
• Drinnon, R. (1980). Facing East from Indian Country. Minnesota University Press.
• Brown, P. (1895). The Indian Problem and Civil War. Journal of American History, 2(3), 245-268.
• Rowland, L. (2009). Native American Involvement in the Civil War. Civil War History Journal, 55(1), 89-114.
• Sundstrom, L. (2007). Native Americans and the Civil War. University of Oklahoma Press.
• Prucha, F. P. (1986). American Indian Treaties: The History of a Political Anomaly. University of California Press.
• White, R. (2011). The Indian Civil War: Native American Alliances and the Civil War. Oxford University Press.