As You Watch The Video Warren Jeffs' World Of Polygamy

1as You Watch The Videowarrenjeffsworld Of Polygamyconsidered Whe

Consider whether having multiple wives should be lawful in the United States. Reflect on the ethical, legal, and social implications of polygamy, especially in the context of the Warren Jeffs case, who was convicted for his role in the Utah-based Fundamentalist Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints (FLDS). Analyze whether Warren Jeffs deserved the harshest sentence, including whether he should have been sentenced to death, considering perspectives from the reading "What is Marriage," "What is Family," the video, the textbook, or other credible resources. Evaluate the societal impacts of polygamy and how it aligns or conflicts with American values and laws.

Paper For Above instruction

Polygamy, the practice of having more than one spouse simultaneously, remains a controversial subject within the United States. While the federal government and most states prohibit plural marriage, certain religious communities continue to practice it secretly or openly. The case of Warren Jeffs, a leader of the FLDS Church, brings to the forefront critical ethical and legal questions regarding polygamy. Jeffs was convicted of multiple charges for his role in arranging marriages between underage girls and young women—acts that are legally and morally condemned in contemporary society.

Legally, the U.S. Supreme Court and various state courts have upheld laws prohibiting polygamy, citing concerns over gender inequality, exploitation, and child abuse. From a moral perspective, "What is Marriage" emphasizes that marriage should be based on mutual consent, equality, and respect. Considering Jeffs's actions, including coercion and abuse, it is argued that his conduct violates fundamental principles of human rights and personal autonomy (Fletcher, 2004). Therefore, legal punishment, including imprisonment, is justified for those who exploit religious beliefs to commit abuse.

The question of whether polygamy should be lawful hinges on respecting religious freedom while protecting individuals from harm. The First Amendment protects religious practices; however, when these practices infringe on others’ rights or involve illegal acts, the government has a compelling interest in intervening (McConnell, 2004). Consequently, permitting polygamous marriages that involve minors or coercion is incompatible with U.S. laws and moral standards.

In the case of Warren Jeffs, his sentencing reflects societal condemnation of the exploitation and abuse associated with certain forms of polygamy. While some argue for religious tolerance, Jeffs’s actions went beyond acceptable religious expression and entered into criminal conduct. Given his role in facilitating underage marriages and abuse, the criminal justice system’s response—imprisonment—was appropriate, but not necessarily the death penalty. The death penalty, reserved for the most heinous crimes, is not typically applied in such cases unless there is direct evidence of murder or intentional harm resulting in death (Simons & Rae, 2020).

In conclusion, polygamy should remain illegal in the United States when it involves coercion, underage marriage, or abuse. While religious freedom is protected, it does not permit practices that violate other citizens’ rights or harm vulnerable populations. Warren Jeffs’s conviction aligns with the need to uphold laws that protect personal safety and human dignity. The debate over polygamy reflects broader issues of religious rights versus legal protections against exploitation.

References

• Fletcher, J. (2004). The Evolution of Marriage in America. Journal of Family History, 29(2), 123-139.
• McConnell, M. (2004). Religious freedoms and the law: An overview. Harvard Law Review, 117(4), 1023-1050.
• Simons, K., & Rae, M. (2020). Criminal law and the death penalty. American Criminal Law Review, 57(1), 89-112.
• Utah State Courts. (2014). Case regarding Warren Jeffs. Retrieved from https://www.utcourts.gov
• Warren Jeffs Conviction and Sentencing. (2011). Retrieved from https://www.npr.org
• Appleby, R. (2017). The impact of polygamy on women and children. Social Science Journal, 54(3), 234-250.
• Brown, L. (2012). Religious freedom vs. legal restrictions: A case study. Law & Society Review, 46(1), 45-67.
• Johnson, T. (2019). The psychology of religious obedience. Psychology Today, March 15.
• U.S. Department of Justice. (2022). Religious liberty laws and enforcement. Retrieved from https://www.justice.gov
• Smith, D. (2015). Family law and religious practices: A legal overview. Family Law Quarterly, 49(2), 250–278.