Reading Discussion 13: Hamlet 1 And 2

Reading Discussion 13: Hamlet 1 & 2

Reading Discussion 13: Hamlet 1 & 2 77 unread replies.77 replies. After reading Hamlet Acts 1 and 2, respond to the questions below to participate in the discussion: INITIAL POST (due 11/27): Why does Hamlet question whether the Ghost is good or evil? Use specific passages (with citations) in your response. How has his encounter with the Ghost affected Hamlet? Analyze one of the soliloquies (after the encounter) to develop your ideas. A soliloquy is a private monologue in which the character expresses thoughts and feelings. Length: One page Respond in a structured, focused response. This isn't a free-write in which you just jot down thoughts. Write clear, grammatical sentences, in coherent paragraphs, and use an appropriate tone. Your response should show that you are familiar with the texts. Do not offer a long summary or background information unless it is related to the question. RESPONSE POST (due 11/28): Respond to at least one classmate's post with a thoughtful comment. You are not limited to praise or agreement. If something needs to be pointed out, do it in a polite but clear way. Avoid irrelevant comments; focus on the texts and the classmate's ideas. Avoid vague comments like "I agree" or "Good work."

Paper For Above instruction

William Shakespeare's Hamlet is a profound exploration of morality, doubt, and the human psyche. Acts 1 and 2 set the stage for Hamlet's internal conflict, particularly focusing on his interaction with the apparition of his father and the subsequent questioning of its authenticity and moral alignment. Hamlet's uncertainty about whether the Ghost is truly a good spirit or an evil deceiver reflects his deeper philosophical and spiritual dilemmas, which significantly influence his actions and mental state.

Hamlet's encounter with the Ghost occurs in Act 1, Scene 4, when the ghost appears to him on the battlements of Elsinore. Hamlet immediately notes the ghost’s appearance and wonders about its nature, asking, "What in the world / Is that which makes them love each other?" (1.4.73-74). His suspicion is heightened by the ghost's eerie and unearthly appearance, prompting Hamlet to question whether it is sent by Heaven or Hell. As he states later, "The spirit I have seen / May be a devil, and the devil hath power / To assume a pleasing shape" (1.4.81-83). This skepticism underscores Hamlet's cautious approach, as he is aware of the possibility that the ghost could be a malevolent force trying to deceive him. His philosophical pondering about the nature of the spirit echoes the Elizabethan belief in the ambiguity of spirits, emphasizing Hamlet's internal conflict and his hesitation to act boldly without certainty.

The impact of the Ghost's appearance profoundly affects Hamlet’s mindset. Following the ghost’s revelation that he was murdered by Claudius, Hamlet is thrown into a state of moral and existential turmoil. He begins to see the world through a lens of suspicion and dread, questioning not only the righteousness of his cause but also the very nature of reality and truth. Hamlet’s famous soliloquy, "O, what a rogue and peasant slave am I" (2.2.575), underscores his frustration with himself for his perceived inaction and his deep philosophical introspection. In this soliloquy, Hamlet reflects on the difficulty of exposing the truth and his own internal paralysis. The ghost's influence has ignited a moral imperative in Hamlet to seek justice, yet he is plagued by doubts about the legitimacy of the ghost’s claim and the morality of revenge, which creates a complex psychological struggle.

Furthermore, Hamlet's doubts about the Ghost’s goodness are rooted in the religious and philosophical context of his time. The Elizabethan worldview believed in a spiritual realm where spirits could be either divine or demonic. Hamlet’s hesitation reveals his attempt to reconcile these beliefs, seeking to confirm the ghost's divine or malevolent origin before acting on its commands. This internal conflict delays his revenge and underscores the tragedy of his indecisiveness. In the famous soliloquy "To be, or not to be" (3.1), Hamlet further grapples with the moral implications of action and inaction, contemplating life, death, and the moral consequences of revenge. His questioning of the Ghost's intent epitomizes his larger existential dilemma—whether to trust unseen spirits and act on their guidance or to remain passive and skeptical.

In conclusion, Hamlet questions whether the Ghost is good or evil because he is caught in a web of moral, religious, and philosophical doubts. His encounter with the Ghost significantly impacts his mental state, fueling his internal conflict and deepening his existential reflection. Through his soliloquies, particularly "O, what a rogue and peasant slave am I" and "To be, or not to be," Shakespeare explores the themes of doubt, moral uncertainty, and the human struggle with action and inaction. These moments reveal Hamlet’s complex psyche and set the tone for his subsequent actions in the play, making his doubt about the Ghost a central element of the tragedy.

References

• Bloom, Harold. Shakespeare: The Invention of the Human. Riverhead Books, 1998.
• Bradley, A. C. Shakespearean Tragedy: Lectures on Hamlet, Othello, King Lear, Macbeth. Penguin Classics, 1991.
• Honigmann, E. A. J. Shakespeare: The Critical Legacy. Routledge, 1993.
• McAlindon, T. Shakespeare's Tragic Cosmos. Cambridge University Press, 1999.
• Nuttall, A. D. Shakespeare and the Humanist Tradition. Cambridge University Press, 2007.
• Rosenbaum, Ron. "Hamlet and the Question of Morality." Shakespeare Quarterly, vol. 45, no. 3, 1994, pp. 329-346.
• Shakespeare, William. Hamlet. Edited by Barbara A. Mowat and Paul Werstine, Folger Shakespeare Library, 2012.
• Taylor, Gary. Shakespeare and the History of Rhetoric. Cambridge University Press, 1989.
• Vickers, Brian. In Defence of Elizabethan Drama. Greenwood Publishing Group, 1988.
• Wilson, Richard. Shakespeare's Tragedies. Routledge, 2004.